The Auto Channel
The Largest Independent Automotive Research Resource
The Largest Independent Automotive Research Resource
Official Website of the New Car Buyer

Memorial Day Alert: Enterprise, National, Alamo Refueling Charges Half What Competitors Charge; Consumers Should Compare Prices or Risk Sticker Shock

ST. LOUIS--As the busy Memorial Day weekend approaches, thousands of travelers may get a shock at the airport rental car counter: return a vehicle with no time to fill up the tank, only to get hit with a staggering $7-$8 per gallon refueling charge from many of the major car rental brands.

With the cost of self-serve gasoline averaging about $2 per gallon, the parent company of Enterprise Rent-A-Car, National Car Rental and Alamo Rent A Car agrees that just doesn’t add up.

Enterprise, National and Alamo charge customers only about $3 per gallon when they bring a car back to the airport without a full tank of gas (depending on market pricing). From Boston to Phoenix, that’s roughly 65 percent less than what some of the other major car rental brands charge their customers.

Enterprise, National and Alamo already led the car rental industry with the most competitive and fair refueling policies in the country. In fact, last year the Maryland Attorney General’s Office announced agreements with other rental car operators to bring their refueling prices more in line with the much lower rates charged by Enterprise, National and Alamo. At the time, the Baltimore Sun referred to Enterprise, National and Alamo’s practices as “a model in setting refueling rates.”

Airport customers continue to have several refueling options with Enterprise, National and Alamo – returning their rental vehicles full of gas, prepaying for a full tank at a discount, or asking for the tank to be refilled after returning the rental car.

“We remain committed to charging a reasonable fee to cover refueling costs,” said Matthew Darrah, senior vice president of North American operations for Enterprise, National and Alamo. “Furthermore, because refueling rates sometimes can be a source of confusion, we’ve revised our policy to provide not only value, but also greater transparency and clarity.”

Effective immediately, Enterprise, National and Alamo airport customers will pay the local-market price of self-serve gasoline, plus a mark-up not to exceed 50 percent of the fuel cost. “Our policy is now based on familiar and highly visible self-serve gas prices,” explained Darrah. “In the end, it is about listening to customers. It is the same approach that is behind our promise never to charge our customers a so-called Energy Recovery Fee.”

In 2008, several major car rental companies began charging customers Energy Recovery Fees on top of their extremely high refueling charges. Although gasoline prices eventually dropped, many of their Energy Recovery Fees remained. However, Enterprise, National and Alamo never implemented Energy Recovery Fees because – as Darrah noted during his keynote address at the annual Car Rental Show last month – these fees are unfair, misleading and almost impossible to calculate.

“We believe that our refueling policy and our position on arbitrary Energy Recovery Fees underscore the fact that car rental companies need to deal with consumers in a fair, honest and transparent way across all areas of service,” Darrah noted. “As the industry leader, we try to set an example on behalf of the customer – and we urge the rest of the industry to do the same.”

 

Average Car Rental Refueling Fees at Major U.S. Airports ( April 2009 )

 

U.S. AIRPORTS

 

Avis Budget

 

Hertz

 

Dollar Thrifty

 

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

National Car Rental

Alamo Rent A Car

Atlanta   $6.99/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $2.85/Gallon
Boston   $7.89/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $7.89/Gallon   $2.89/Gallon
Chicago   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $3.31/Gallon
Dallas-Ft. Worth   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $2.82/Gallon
Denver   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $2.93/Gallon
Houston   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.89/Gallon   $2.89/Gallon
Las Vegas   $7.99/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $3.07/Gallon
Los Angeles   $7.99/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $3.32/Gallon
Miami   $7.44/Gallon   $8.59/Gallon   $6.50/Gallon   $3.18/Gallon
Minn.-St. Paul   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.89/Gallon   $2.84/Gallon
Orlando   $6.99/Gallon   $7.19/Gallon   $5.59/Gallon   $3.02/Gallon
Palm Beach   $7.99/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $3.07/Gallon
Phoenix   $7.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $2.74/Gallon
Pittsburgh   $6.99/Gallon   $7.49/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $2.94/Gallon
St. Louis   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $6.99/Gallon   $2.74/Gallon
Seattle   $7.99/Gallon   $7.99/Gallon   $5.99/Gallon   $3.30/Gallon
       

Note: data collected by Enterprise, National and Alamo during April 2009